Specific values which can be stored or used at run-time.

• §1. Testing
• §2. Named constants
• §9. Literals as rvalues
• §20. Pairs
• §21. Constant descriptions
• §22. Testing
• §24. Pretty-printing
• §25. Kind

§1. Testing. An "rvalue" is a specification of an single piece of data, such as a number, a text or a choice of object. This detects whether a specification is one:

int Rvalues::is_rvalue?Usage of Rvalues::is_rvalue:
Specifications - §1, §7(parse_node *pn) {
    node_type_metadata *metadata = NodeType::get_metadata(Node::get_type(pn));
    if ((metadata) && (metadata->category == RVALUE_NCAT)) return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

§2. Named constants. Constant nodes can store references to many of the structures in this compiler: for example, each table * pointer in Inform corresponds to a constant node representing the name of that table.

Dealing with these is very repetitive, and we use macros to define the relevant routines. Firstly, creating a CONSTANT node from one of these pointers:

define CONV_FROM(structure, K)
    parse_node *spec = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K);
    Node::set_constant_##structure(spec, val);
    return spec;

parse_node *Rvalues::from_activity(activity *val) {
        CONV_FROM(activity, Activities::to_kind(val)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_binary_predicate(binary_predicate *val) {
        CONV_FROM(binary_predicate, Kinds::base_construction(CON_relation)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_constant_phrase(constant_phrase *val) {
        CONV_FROM(constant_phrase, Kinds::base_construction(CON_phrase)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_equation?Usage of Rvalues::from_equation:
Type Expressions and Values - §11.1, §11.3(equation *val) {
        CONV_FROM(equation, K_equation) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_named_rulebook_outcome(named_rulebook_outcome *val) {
        CONV_FROM(named_rulebook_outcome, K_rulebook_outcome) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_property(property *val) {
        CONV_FROM(property, Properties::to_kind(val)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_rule(rule *val) {
        CONV_FROM(rule, Rules::to_kind(val)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_rulebook(rulebook *val) {
        CONV_FROM(rulebook, Rulebooks::to_kind(val)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_table(table *val) {
        CONV_FROM(table, K_table) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_table_column(table_column *val) {
        CONV_FROM(table_column, Tables::Columns::to_kind(val)) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_use_option(use_option *val) {
        CONV_FROM(use_option, K_use_option) }
parse_node *Rvalues::from_verb_form?Usage of Rvalues::from_verb_form:
Constants and Descriptions - §1.1(verb_form *val) {
        if (RTVerbs::verb_form_is_instance(val) == FALSE)
            internal_error("created rvalue for non-instance verb form");
        CONV_FROM(verb_form, K_verb) }

§3. Contrariwise, here's how to get back again:

define CONV_TO(structure)
    if (spec == NULL) return NULL;
    structure *val = Node::get_constant_##structure(spec);
    return val;

activity *Rvalues::to_activity?Usage of Rvalues::to_activity:
§23(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(activity) }
binary_predicate *Rvalues::to_binary_predicate?Usage of Rvalues::to_binary_predicate:
§4, §23, §25.2(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(binary_predicate) }
constant_phrase *Rvalues::to_constant_phrase?Usage of Rvalues::to_constant_phrase:
§23, §25.6(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(constant_phrase) }
equation *Rvalues::to_equation?Usage of Rvalues::to_equation:
Type Expressions and Values - §11.2(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(equation) }
named_rulebook_outcome *Rvalues::to_named_rulebook_outcome(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(named_rulebook_outcome) }
property *Rvalues::to_property?Usage of Rvalues::to_property:
§23, §25.3
Lvalues - §11, §12.5
Dash - §10.9.1.1.2.1, §10.9.1.1.5.1.2, §10.9.1.2.3, §12, §18.3(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(property) }
rule *Rvalues::to_rule?Usage of Rvalues::to_rule:
§23(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(rule) }
int Rvalues::to_response_marker(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, K_response)) {
        wording SW = Node::get_text(spec);
        if ((Wordings::length(SW) >= 2) &&
            (<response-letter>(Wordings::one_word(Wordings::last_wn(SW)-1))))
            return <<r>>;
    }
    return -1;
}
rulebook *Rvalues::to_rulebook?Usage of Rvalues::to_rulebook:
§23(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(rulebook) }
table *Rvalues::to_table(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(table) }
table_column *Rvalues::to_table_column?Usage of Rvalues::to_table_column:
§23, §25.5
Lvalues - §12.3(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(table_column) }
use_option *Rvalues::to_use_option(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(use_option) }
verb_form *Rvalues::to_verb_form(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(verb_form) }

§4.

define VALUE_TO_RELATION_FUNCTION Rvalues::to_binary_predicate

§5. With enumerated kinds, the possible values are in general stored as instance objects.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_instance?Usage of Rvalues::from_instance:
Descriptions - §5(instance *I) {
    parse_node *val = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(val, Instances::to_kind(I));
    Node::set_constant_instance(val, I);
    Annotations::write_int(val, constant_enumeration_ANNOT, Instances::get_numerical_value(I));
    Node::set_text(val, Instances::get_name(I, FALSE));
    return val;
}

instance *Rvalues::to_instance?Usage of Rvalues::to_instance:
§6, §23, §25.1
Specifications - §5
Descriptions - §5
Verbal and Relative Clauses - §6.1
Dash - §10.9.1.1.5.1.1(parse_node *spec) {
        CONV_TO(instance) }

§6. An instance of a subkind of K_object is called an "object":

int Rvalues::is_object?Usage of Rvalues::is_object:
§25
Specifications - §3, §5
Dash - §10.9.1.2.3(parse_node *spec) {
    if ((Node::is(spec, CONSTANT_NT)) &&
        (Kinds::Behaviour::is_object(Node::get_kind_of_value(spec))))
        return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

instance *Rvalues::to_object_instance?Usage of Rvalues::to_object_instance:
§23
Constants and Descriptions - §12
Dash - §10.9.1.1.5.1(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_object(spec)) return Rvalues::to_instance(spec);
    return NULL;
}

§7. There are two pseudo-objects for which no pointers to instance can exist: "self" and "nothing". These cause nothing but trouble and are marked out with special annotations.

parse_node *Rvalues::new_self_object_constant?Usage of Rvalues::new_self_object_constant:
Dash - §18.3.1.1(void) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_object);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, self_object_ANNOT, TRUE);
    return spec;
}

parse_node *Rvalues::new_nothing_object_constant?Usage of Rvalues::new_nothing_object_constant:
Constants and Descriptions - §1(void) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_object);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, nothing_object_ANNOT, TRUE);
    return spec;
}

§8. To test for the self/nothing anomalies (that really could be an episode title from "The Big Bang Theory"),

int Rvalues::is_nothing_object_constant?Usage of Rvalues::is_nothing_object_constant:
Specifications - §3, §5, §10
Dash - §18(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Annotations::read_int(spec, nothing_object_ANNOT)) return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

int Rvalues::is_self_object_constant?Usage of Rvalues::is_self_object_constant:
Lvalues - §7
Dash - §10.9.1.2.3(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Annotations::read_int(spec, self_object_ANNOT)) return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

§9. Literals as rvalues. Notation such as "24 kg" is converted inside Inform into a suitable integer, perhaps 24000, and the following turns that into an rvalue:

parse_node *Rvalues::from_encoded_notation?Usage of Rvalues::from_encoded_notation:
Literal Patterns - §37(kind *K, int encoded_value, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, encoded_value);
    return spec;
}

int Rvalues::to_encoded_notation?Usage of Rvalues::to_encoded_notation:
§23
Literal Patterns - §27.2(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Annotations::read_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0;
}

§10. We can also convert to and from integers, but there we use an integer annotation, not a pointer one.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_int?Usage of Rvalues::from_int:
Parsing Literals - §1(int n, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_number);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, n);
    return spec;
}

int Rvalues::to_int(parse_node *spec) {
    if (spec == NULL) return 0;
    if (Annotations::read_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0;
}

§11. Internally we represent parsed reals as unsigned integers holding their IEEE-754 representations; I don't sufficiently trust C's implementation of float to be consistent across all Inform's platforms to use that instead.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_IEEE_754?Usage of Rvalues::from_IEEE_754:
Literal Real Numbers - §1(unsigned int n, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_real_number);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, (int) n);
    return spec;
}

unsigned int Rvalues::to_IEEE_754(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, K_real_number))
        return (unsigned int) Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0x7F800001;  which is a NaN value
}

§12. And exactly similarly, truth states:

parse_node *Rvalues::from_boolean?Usage of Rvalues::from_boolean:
Parsing Literals - §3(int flag, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_truth_state);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, flag);
    return spec;
}

int Rvalues::to_boolean(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, K_truth_state))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return FALSE;
}

§13. And Unicode character values.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_Unicode?Usage of Rvalues::from_Unicode:
Unicode Literals - §1(int code_point, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_unicode_character);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, code_point);
    return spec;
}

int Rvalues::to_Unicode_point?Usage of Rvalues::to_Unicode_point:
Transcoding Text - §4(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, K_unicode_character))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0;
}

§14. Version numbers require three integers.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_version?Usage of Rvalues::from_version:
Literal Version Numbers - §1(semantic_version_number V, wording W) {
    semantic_version_number_holder *H = CREATE(semantic_version_number_holder);
    H->version = V;
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_constant_version_number(spec, H);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_version_number);
    return spec;
}

semantic_version_number Rvalues::to_version(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, K_version_number)) {
        semantic_version_number_holder *H = Node::get_constant_version_number(spec);
        return H->version;
    }
    return VersionNumbers::null();
}

§15. In the traditional Inform world model, time is measured in minutes, reduced modulo 1440, the number of minutes in a day.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_time?Usage of Rvalues::from_time:
Times of Day - §3, §4(int minutes_since_midnight, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, TimesOfDay::kind());
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, minutes_since_midnight);
    return spec;
}

parse_node *Rvalues::from_time_period?Usage of Rvalues::from_time_period:
Times of Day - §3(int minutes, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, TimesOfDay::time_period());
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT, minutes);
    return spec;
}

int Rvalues::to_time(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, TimesOfDay::kind()))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0;
}

int Rvalues::to_time_period(parse_node *spec) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind(spec, TimesOfDay::time_period()))
        return Annotations::read_int(spec, constant_number_ANNOT);
    return 0;
}

§16. For obscure timing reasons, we store literal lists as just their wordings together with their kinds:

parse_node *Rvalues::from_wording_of_list?Usage of Rvalues::from_wording_of_list:
Literal Lists - §2(kind *K, wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K);
    return spec;
}

§17. Text mostly comes from wordings:

parse_node *Rvalues::from_wording?Usage of Rvalues::from_wording:
§18
Parsing Literals - §1(wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_text);
    return spec;
}

§18. It's convenient to have a version for text where square brackets should be interpreted literally, not as escapes for a text substitution:

parse_node *Rvalues::from_unescaped_wording(wording W) {
    parse_node *spec = Rvalues::from_wording(W);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, text_unescaped_ANNOT, TRUE);
    return spec;
}

§19.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_iname(inter_name *I) {
    parse_node *spec = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K_text);
    Annotations::write_int(spec, explicit_literal_ANNOT, TRUE);
    Node::set_explicit_iname(spec, I);
    return spec;
}

§20. Pairs. We can also form an r-value by combining two existing values; note that in Inform, unlike in (say) Perl, a tuple of l-values is only an r-value, not an l-value.

parse_node *Rvalues::from_pair?Usage of Rvalues::from_pair:
Verbal and Relative Clauses - §4(parse_node *X, parse_node *Y) {
    if (X == NULL) X = Specifications::new_UNKNOWN(EMPTY_WORDING);
    if (Y == NULL) Y = Specifications::new_UNKNOWN(EMPTY_WORDING);
    kind *kX = Specifications::to_true_kind_disambiguated(X);
    kind *kY = Specifications::to_true_kind_disambiguated(Y);
    kind *K = Kinds::pair_kind(kX, kY);
    parse_node *spec = Node::new(CONSTANT_NT);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(spec, K);
    spec->down = X; spec->down->next = Y;
    return spec;
}

void Rvalues::to_pair(parse_node *pair, parse_node **X, parse_node **Y) {
    *X = pair->down;
    *Y = pair->down->next;
}

§21. Constant descriptions. Note that whenever we change the proposition, the kind of the constant may in principle change, since that depends on the free variable's kind in the proposition.

parse_node *Rvalues::constant_description?Usage of Rvalues::constant_description:
Descriptions - §1(pcalc_prop *prop, wording W) {
    parse_node *con = Node::new_with_words(CONSTANT_NT, W);
    Node::set_kind_of_value(con,
        Kinds::unary_con(CON_description, K_object));
    Rvalues::set_constant_description_proposition(con, prop);
    return con;
}

void Rvalues::set_constant_description_proposition?Usage of Rvalues::set_constant_description_proposition:
Descriptions - §2(parse_node *spec, pcalc_prop *prop) {
    if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_description)) {
        Node::set_proposition(spec, prop);
        Node::set_kind_of_value(spec,
            Kinds::unary_con(CON_description,
                Binding::infer_kind_of_variable_0(prop)));
    } else internal_error("set constant description proposition wrongly");
}

§22. Testing.

int Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction?Usage of Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction:
§21, §24, §25
Specifications - §3
Lvalues - §11
Descriptions - §1, §2, §6
Constants and Descriptions - §3, §5
Dash - §9.1.1.3.1.3, §10.9.1.1.2.1, §10.9.1.1.3.1.1, §10.9.1.1.5.1, §10.9.1.1.5.1.2, §12, §18.3(parse_node *spec, kind_constructor *con) {
    if ((Node::is(spec, CONSTANT_NT)) &&
        (Kinds::get_construct(Node::get_kind_of_value(spec)) == con))
        return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

int Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind?Usage of Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_of_kind:
§3, §11, §12, §13, §14, §15
Literal Patterns - §27.2
Enter the S-Parser - §11
Constants and Descriptions - §3, §5
Type Expressions and Values - §11.2
Conditions and Phrases - §10.1
Dash - §16, §18.5.2(parse_node *spec, kind *K) {
    if ((Node::is(spec, CONSTANT_NT)) &&
        (Kinds::eq(Node::get_kind_of_value(spec), K)))
        return TRUE;
    return FALSE;
}

§23. Our most elaborate test is a finicky one, checking if two constant values are equal at compile time — which is needed when seeing how to mesh table continuations together, and in rare cases to help the typechecker. This doesn't need to be especially rapid.

define COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(DATA, STRUCTURE, FETCH)
    if (Kinds::get_construct(K1) == DATA) {
        STRUCTURE *x1 = FETCH(spec1);
        STRUCTURE *x2 = FETCH(spec2);
        if (x1 == x2) return TRUE;
        return FALSE;
    }
define KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(DATA, STRUCTURE, FETCH)
    if (Kinds::eq(K1, K_##DATA)) {
        STRUCTURE *x1 = FETCH(spec1);
        STRUCTURE *x2 = FETCH(spec2);
        if (x1 == x2) return TRUE;
        return FALSE;
    }
define KKCOMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(DATA, STRUCTURE, FETCH)
    if (Kinds::conforms_to(K1, K_##DATA)) {
        STRUCTURE *x1 = FETCH(spec1);
        STRUCTURE *x2 = FETCH(spec2);
        if (x1 == x2) return TRUE;
        return FALSE;
    }
define KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS(DATA, STRUCTURE)
    KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(DATA, STRUCTURE, Rvalues::to_##STRUCTURE)

int Rvalues::compare_CONSTANT?Usage of Rvalues::compare_CONSTANT:
Dash - §10.6(parse_node *spec1, parse_node *spec2) {
    if (Node::is(spec1, CONSTANT_NT) == FALSE) return FALSE;
    if (Node::is(spec2, CONSTANT_NT) == FALSE) return FALSE;
    kind *K1 = Node::get_kind_of_value(spec1);
    kind *K2 = Node::get_kind_of_value(spec2);
    if ((Kinds::conforms_to(K1, K2) == FALSE) &&
        (Kinds::conforms_to(K2, K1) == FALSE)) return FALSE;
    if (Kinds::eq(K1, K_text)) {
        if (Wordings::match_perhaps_quoted(
            Node::get_text(spec1), Node::get_text(spec2))) return TRUE;
        return FALSE;
    }
    switch (Kinds::Behaviour::get_constant_compilation_method(K1)) {
        case LITERAL_CCM:
            if (Rvalues::to_encoded_notation(spec1) ==
                Rvalues::to_encoded_notation(spec2)) return TRUE;
            return FALSE;
        case NAMED_CONSTANT_CCM: {
            instance *I1 = Rvalues::to_instance(spec1);
            instance *I2 = Rvalues::to_instance(spec2);
            if (I1 == I2) return TRUE;
            return FALSE;
        }
        case SPECIAL_CCM: {
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_activity, activity, Rvalues::to_activity)
            KKCOMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(object, instance, Rvalues::to_object_instance)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_phrase, constant_phrase, Rvalues::to_constant_phrase)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_property, property, Rvalues::to_property)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_rule, rule, Rvalues::to_rule)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_rulebook, rulebook, Rvalues::to_rulebook)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_table_column, table_column, Rvalues::to_table_column)
            KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS(equation, equation)
            COMPARE_CONSTANTS_USING(CON_relation, binary_predicate, Rvalues::to_binary_predicate)
            KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS(rulebook_outcome, named_rulebook_outcome)
            KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS(table, table)
            KCOMPARE_CONSTANTS(use_option, use_option)
            int rv = NOT_APPLICABLE;
            PluginCalls::compare_constant(spec1, spec2, &rv);
            if (rv != NOT_APPLICABLE) return rv;
        }
    }
    return FALSE;
}

§24. Pretty-printing.

void Rvalues::write_out_in_English?Usage of Rvalues::write_out_in_English:
Specifications - §7(OUTPUT_STREAM, parse_node *spec) {
    switch (Node::get_type(spec)) {
        case PHRASE_TO_DECIDE_VALUE_NT: {
            kind *dtr = Specifications::to_kind(spec);
            if (dtr == NULL) WRITE("a phrase");
            else {
                WRITE("an instruction to work out ");
                Kinds::Textual::write_articled(OUT, dtr);
            }
            break;
        }
        case CONSTANT_NT: {
            wording W = Node::get_text(spec);
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_property)) {
                if (Wordings::nonempty(W)) WRITE("%+W", W);
                else WRITE("the name of a property");
                return;
            }
            if (Wordings::nonempty(W)) WRITE("%+W", W);
            else {
                WRITE("a nameless ");
                kind *dtr = Specifications::to_kind(spec);
                Kinds::Textual::write(OUT, dtr);
            }
            break;
        }
    }
}

§25. Kind. Clearly everything in this family evaluates, but what kind does the result have?

kind *Rvalues::to_kind?Usage of Rvalues::to_kind:
Specifications - §1
Lvalues - §12
Literal Patterns - §27.3(parse_node *spec) {
    if (spec == NULL) internal_error("Rvalues::to_kind on NULL");
    switch (Node::get_type(spec)) {
        case CONSTANT_NT:
            if (Rvalues::is_object(spec))
                Work out the kind for a constant object25.1;
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_relation))
                Work out the kind for a constant relation25.2;
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_property))
                Work out the kind for a constant property name25.3;
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_phrase))
                Work out the kind for a constant phrase25.6;
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_list_of))
                Work out the kind for a constant list25.4;
            if (Rvalues::is_CONSTANT_construction(spec, CON_table_column))
                Work out the kind for a table column25.5;
            return Node::get_kind_of_value(spec);
        case PHRASE_TO_DECIDE_VALUE_NT:
            Work out the kind returned by a phrase25.7;
    }
    internal_error("unknown evaluating VALUE type"); return NULL;
}

§25.1. Work out the kind for a constant object25.1 =

    if (Annotations::read_int(spec, self_object_ANNOT)) return K_object;
    else if (Annotations::read_int(spec, nothing_object_ANNOT)) return K_object;
    else {
        instance *I = Rvalues::to_instance(spec);
        if (I) return Instances::to_kind(I);
    }

• This code is used in §25.

§25.2. Work out the kind for a constant relation25.2 =

    binary_predicate *bp = Rvalues::to_binary_predicate(spec);
    return BinaryPredicates::kind(bp);

• This code is used in §25.

§25.3. Work out the kind for a constant property name25.3 =

    property *prn = Rvalues::to_property(spec);
    if (prn->either_or_data) return Kinds::unary_con(CON_property, K_truth_state);
    return Kinds::unary_con(CON_property, ValueProperties::kind(prn));

• This code is used in §25.

§25.4. Work out the kind for a constant list25.4 =

    return Lists::kind_of_list_at(Node::get_text(spec));

• This code is used in §25.

§25.5. Work out the kind for a table column25.5 =

    return Kinds::unary_con(CON_table_column,
        Tables::Columns::get_kind(Rvalues::to_table_column(spec)));

• This code is used in §25.

§25.6. A timing issue here means that the kind will be vague until the second assertion traverse:

Work out the kind for a constant phrase25.6 =

    return ToPhraseFamily::kind(Rvalues::to_constant_phrase(spec));

• This code is used in §25.

§25.7. This too is tricky. Some phrases to decide values are unambiguous. If they say they are "To decide a rule: ...", then clearly the return value will be a rule. But others are "polymorphic" — Greek for many-shaped, but in this context, it means that the return value's kind depends on the kinds of its arguments; addition is like this, for instance.

Compounding the problem is that we don't actually know which phrase will be invoked — we only have a list of possibilities. All of them return values, but those may have different kinds, and some may be polymorphic.

So what are we to do? First, we find the "deciding invocation": the first entry in the list which has been passed by the type-checker, or if none of them has, then the first entry of all. If the deciding invocation is of a phrase with an unambiguous kind, then that's of course the answer. If it is polymorphic, then we look to see if typechecking has already resolved the difficulty by showing the result, and if so, then that's the answer. The worst case, then, is when we have a polymorphic phrase and typechecking hasn't yet sorted matters out — in that event we return simply "value" as the kind, an extremely weak if certainly true answer.

We resort to returning NULL, an unknown kind, only when the invocation list is empty. This should never happen except possibly after recovering from some problem message.

Work out the kind returned by a phrase25.7 =

    parse_node *deciding_inv = spec->down->down;
    if (deciding_inv) {
        id_body *idb = Node::get_phrase_invoked(deciding_inv);
        if ((idb) && (IDTypeData::get_mor(&(idb->type_data)) == DECIDES_VALUE_MOR)) {
            if (IDTypeData::return_decided_dimensionally(&(idb->type_data))) {
                if (Node::get_kind_resulting(deciding_inv))
                    return Node::get_kind_resulting(deciding_inv);
                return K_value;
            } else {
                if (Node::get_kind_resulting(deciding_inv))
                    return Node::get_kind_resulting(deciding_inv);
                kind *K = IDTypeData::get_return_kind(&(idb->type_data));
                if (Kinds::Behaviour::definite(K) == FALSE) return K_value;
                return K;
            }
        }
    }
    return NULL;

• This code is used in §25.